Excuse Me, Are You A Tissue Pack?
Terence Lim Eu Seng said:
“Using tissue packs instead of leaving one member behind are merely two different approaches with the same result of the table being unavailable to the waiting patron anyway, who thus has what cause for complaint?”
Terence seems to be unaware that a person telling you that the seat next to his is occupied will not be sitting there just to tell you that the seat next to his is occupied. He is waiting for someone to come back. Once that person is back and they have both eaten, it’s unlikely that they’ll continue to occupy the seats for long. Try telling that to a forgotten tissue pack. It could have been left there long before lunchtime and it can stay there indefinitely. A tissue pack will obediently stay on the seat even if you take 2 hours to get your food. A human companion who needs to go back to work will not wait that long.
I definitely see the difference between a tissue pack and a human being and I’m not ashamed to say that I trust the latter more. People like Terence may have been letting his tissue packs do the talking for him, but frankly, I’m not so sure if I want to communicate with his tisue packs.
Well, one can afford to offend tissue packs, but certainly not a giant like China. South Africa has just denied the Dalai Lama his visa, effectively barring the exiled spiritual leader from a Nobel peace conference. China may not have insisted on that, but fearing the diplomatic consequences, South Africa has chosen to play safe. It’s a little like self-censorship and South Africa is certainly not the first and won’t be the last country to do that.
Remember a time when our monopolised media was busy singing praises for “Asian values” while condemning the “decadent West”? I’m always proud of my own culture and Asian identity, but I have never felt so ashamed of all the arrogant, self-centered and downright ridiculous remarks that the newsmakers in Singapore made. Of course, there was a motive behind all this. Just after the first Gulf War, the US was in recession and ambitious state-run enterprises were trying their luck in China. When criticised by human rights groups, the media quickly retaliated. Any Asian person who criticised China was instantly branded as someone brainwashed by the Western media. The superiority of Asian values, the unethical Western media … it sounded like world war of words. Thankfully, only political leaders were involved. The rest of us went about our daily affairs, making no enemies with our counterparts in the West just because they have criticised China’s human rights record.

But make no mistake about it, Westerners were not always as gracious and respectful of human rights as they are now. European settlers in Tasmania once hunted native Tasmanian aborigines like they would hunt game animals. These inhuman colonists completely exterminated the indigenous people of Tasmania. The last Tasmanian man had his skin made into a leather pouch.
Our media has been hard at work digging out sins of the American and Australian pioneers. But that’s beside the point. I learned about the Tasmanian genocide from a book by Jared Diamond - an American, a Westerner. Australia’s media will not censor such historical facts and many Australians today would feel ashamed of what some of their ancestors did. Are reflections on the atrocities committed in China’s recent history allowed within China and tolerated outside it?
Nevertheless, there is one thing that I totally agree with the apologists. Do not mix business with human rights. Just because there’s no democracy in China does not mean that you can’t visit China, do business with the Chinese people and have non-political discussions with them. And back to the Dalai Lama’s world tours to lecture on Buddhism and world peace, why can’t China practise what it has been preaching and treat business dealings with countries hosting the Dalai Lama as purely business dealings?

Self censorship and preventive action before any official protest is like reacting to a tissue pack placed on a seat. But when the tissue pack is placed by a big bully with a small heart and narrow mind, it may be better to treat it like an ancient imperial edict read by a eunuch.











